Has the Federal Reserve Left it Too late?
On the 6th of June 2024 The European Central Bank (ECB) cut their interest rates by 0.25%, the Bank of England followed suit on the 1st of August 2024 lowering their interest rates by exactly the same percentage points. However, the US Federal Reserve’s Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) on the 31st of July announced they were once again holding interest rates steady at 5.25% – 5.50% where they have now sat since July 2023. The last time the Federal Reserve cut interest rates was in March 2020, but all eyes are now on the FOMC meeting in September where financial markets and experts are expecting the Federal Reserve to announce a rate cut.
The mood coming out of the Federal Reserve suggests a cooling economy with data showing rising unemployment and moderating job gains. This suggests that the Federal Reserve may well indeed cut rates at their September meeting, but a weakening economy in some cases can spiral into a recession by feeding off itself. So, has the Federal Reserve left it too late to cut interest rates? Economists and financial experts alike remind us that the United States avoided a predicted recession in 2023, which may have resulted in favourable predictions that the US economy would enjoy a soft landing in 2024.
However, the Federal Reserve may have misinterpreted data in a favourable manner due to Q2 enjoying unexpected increased growth figures of 2.8%, which was taken as evidence that the US economy was indeed in good shape. Some analysts have looked beyond this figure and suggest the economic growth has been propped up not only by government spending (which has been backed up by a sizeable deficit) but also by excessive hiring in the public sector. Warning signals such as the ISM Manufacturing New Orders Index* (a bell weather signal for past recessions) is showing signs of decline, in the week ending July 2024 jobless claims rose to an eleven month high and plethora of companies who are consumer focused recently recorded earnings figures misses.
*ISM Manufacturing New Orders Index – This index, which is sometimes referred to as the “Purchasing Managers’ Index”, is considered a key indicator of the current state of the US Economy. It indicates the level of demand for products by measuring the amount of ordering activity at the nation’s factories.
Other warning signals come from the New York Federal Reserve who are suggesting that there is a better than even chance of a recession appearing at some stage in Q3 and Q4. Such predictions are based on “the curve over time of bond yields”* though this has been an unreliable indicator in the past. Experts at a major New York investment bank suggest that the mean or median optimum interest rate (based on a number of monetary policy rules) should be 4%. Yet the Federal Reserve chose not to cut interest rates despite inflation in June coming close (within 0.5%) to their benchmark target of 2%.
*The curve over time of bond yields – If the yield curve is flattening , it raises fears of high inflation and recession. In the event of yield curve inversion this “EVENT” is viewed as the likelihood of the US economy slipping into recession. An inverted yield curve occurs when short-term yields on US Treasuries exceed long-term yields on US Treasuries. This occurred on June 14th, 2024, when the yield for a 10-year treasury was 4.2% and the yield for a 2-year treasury was 4.67%.
Experts suggest that an economy does not slow down in an undeviating manner and, unless checked, an economy can lose economic momentum and spiral out of control into recession. That means that any pricing by the financial markets for a soft landing can quickly go out the window. There are enough warnings out there for the Federal Reserve to take their foot off the brake on interest rate cuts, but will they lament not having cut interest rates in July when the FOMC meets in September.
